Skip to content

Nutritional coaching

Emotional eating: telling emotional hunger from physical hunger

Eating when we feel sad, tired or on edge is more common than it might seem. We explain how to tell emotional hunger from physical hunger, why it happens and when it is worth asking for help.

By The Institut PSIRA team5 min read

A plate of salad with tomato and walnuts, with a fork beside it
Photo: magnific / Magnific
Article contents
  1. Physical hunger and emotional hunger
  2. Why it happens
  3. Strategies that can help
  4. When it might be an eating disorder
  5. How nutritional coaching can help

Opening the fridge after a hard day, snacking when we are bored or reaching for something sweet when we feel low are very common experiences. Food is not just fuel: it is also bound up with memories, celebrations and the ways we comfort ourselves.

Eating for emotional reasons now and then is not a problem. It can become one when it turns into the main way of coping with distress, when it brings guilt or when it leaves you feeling out of control. In this article we look at what lies behind it and which sensible strategies can help.

Physical hunger and emotional hunger

Both are real, but they work differently. Recognising them is the first step towards working out what you need at any given moment.

  • Physical hunger builds gradually, often a few hours after your last meal, and can be satisfied by a wide range of foods.
  • Emotional hunger tends to come on suddenly, is linked to a particular feeling or situation and usually craves a very specific kind of food.
  • With physical hunger it is easier to stop when you have had enough; with emotional hunger it is harder to notice when you are full.
  • After an episode of emotional eating, it is common to feel guilty or as if you did not really choose.

These differences are only a guide. Very often the two overlap, and there is no need to analyse every mouthful: simply starting to notice is enough.

Why it happens

Food brings relief for a while. In the face of stress, sadness, anxiety or boredom, it can act as a quick, readily available comfort. The trouble is that the relief does not last and the underlying feeling is still there.

Many things play a part: tiredness and lack of sleep, skipping meals, having followed very restrictive diets, habits learned at home or the way we have learned to deal with emotions. That is why it makes little sense to treat it as a matter of willpower.

Emotional hunger is not solved by banning foods, but by understanding what you need in that moment and finding other ways to meet it.

Strategies that can help

There is no one-size-fits-all formula, but there are sensible habits that tend to help many people:

  • Eating mindfully: sitting down, away from screens, and paying attention to the taste, the texture and the feeling of fullness.
  • Keeping to routines: regular meals help you avoid arriving very hungry in the evening, which is often when it is hardest.
  • Not banning foods: declaring a food off limits tends to increase the craving and, when you give in, to make you overdo it.
  • Pausing before you eat: asking yourself what you are feeling and what you need can open up other options, such as going for a walk, having a shower or talking to someone.
  • Looking after your rest: too little sleep makes it harder to regulate both appetite and emotions.

This is about small, steady changes, not a test of perfection. Some days will go better than others, and that is part of the process too.

When it might be an eating disorder

Sometimes there is more to emotional eating. If binges are frequent and feel out of control, if they are followed by behaviours to make up for them (vomiting, fasting or excessive exercise), or if weight and body shape take up much of your thoughts, it may be an eating disorder.

In these cases, the first step is a psychological assessment, and support that focuses only on food is not enough. Our Adult Unit diagnoses and treats eating disorders.

How nutritional coaching can help

Our Nutritional Coaching Unit supports people who want to change their relationship with food in a mindful, sustainable way. The work includes a personalised eating plan tailored to your lifestyle, nutrition education so you can make informed choices and motivational tools to help you keep up routines in the long term.

A nutritional coaching session costs €65 and a pack of 3 sessions costs €175. Sessions last 55 minutes and can be held in person or online.

You can book through Doctoralia, message us on WhatsApp on +34 621 404 235 or use the contact form. If anxiety plays a big part, you may also find our article on the signs of anxiety useful.

When to ask for help

It is worth seeking advice if:

  • You often eat to soothe your emotions and feel it is the only way you have of coping with them.
  • You have binges in which you feel you lose control.
  • After eating you feel guilty or ashamed, or want to make up for it.
  • Food, weight or body image take up much of your thoughts.
  • You avoid eating in front of other people.

This article is for general information and does not replace an assessment by a health professional.

A calmer relationship with food

If you would like to understand what lies behind the way you eat, book a first appointment and we will talk it through calmly.

or write to us using the form

More articles

All articles