Skip to content

Forensic psychology

Psychological expert reports in civil law: what they are and how they’re prepared

In custody, parenting capacity or psychological harm cases, an expert report can give the court a professional assessment. We explain what it is, how it’s prepared and what it isn’t.

By The Institut PSIRA team5 min read

A pair of glasses resting on some papers on a table.
Photo: pressfoto / Magnific
Article contents
  1. What a psychological expert report is
  2. When it’s requested and by whom
  3. How it’s prepared
  4. What an expert report is not
  5. Confirming the report in court
  6. Mediation: an alternative worth considering
  7. How we can help at Institut PSIRA

In some court cases, the judge has to make decisions that involve psychological aspects of people’s lives: who the children will live with, how able a parent is to care for them or what impact an event has had on someone’s health. In these cases, a psychological expert report can provide a professional assessment.

Here we explain what it is, who can request one, how it’s prepared and what not to expect from it. This is general information: for legal questions about your own case, your solicitor or lawyer is the person to ask.

What a psychological expert report is

It is a document in which a psychologist, acting as an expert witness, answers specific questions raised in court proceedings. These questions set the scope of the report: what is assessed and what isn’t.

The report sets out the methods used, the findings and reasoned conclusions. It needs to be clear to people who aren’t psychologists, such as the judge or the lawyers, while being rigorous enough to stand up technically.

When it’s requested and by whom

In civil law, psychological expert reports are mainly used in family and personal matters such as these:

  • Custody and contact arrangements.
  • Assessment of parenting capacity.
  • Contested separations and divorces.
  • Assessment of psychological harm following an event.
  • Adoption and fostering, and guardianship or legal capacity support proceedings.

One of the parties can request it, usually through their lawyer, to submit as evidence; the court can also commission it directly. It is often the lawyer who decides whether a report is advisable and when. Families can also contact a forensic psychology service directly to find out more before deciding anything.

How it’s prepared

Each report is tailored to its scope, but the process usually includes these steps:

  1. Interviews with the people involved and, where appropriate, with the children, always adapted to their age.
  2. Standardised psychological tests, chosen according to what needs to be assessed.
  3. Review of documents: previous medical, school or psychological reports and other relevant paperwork.
  4. Writing the report, covering the methods, findings and conclusions.

The expert must act objectively and impartially. Even if one of the parties has instructed them, their role is to assess and report rigorously, not to argue a position: the conclusions come from the evidence, not from whoever commissioned the report.

A good expert report doesn’t take sides: it answers the question it has been asked, rigorously.

What an expert report is not

It’s easy to confuse the role of an expert witness with that of a therapist, but they are different jobs.

  • It isn’t therapy: the aim is to assess, not to treat. If the person needs psychological support, they can get it elsewhere.
  • It isn’t emotional backing: the expert listens respectfully but doesn’t take anyone’s side.
  • It isn’t legal advice: the psychologist doesn’t advise on legal strategy or on how the case will end.
  • It doesn’t guarantee an outcome: the final decision always rests with the judge, who weighs the report alongside the rest of the evidence.

Confirming the report in court

Once the report has been submitted, the expert may be called to court to confirm it. This means standing by its content and answering questions from the judge and the parties’ lawyers about the methods and conclusions.

That’s why the report needs to be well structured, with every conclusion capable of being explained and justified. A sound report is one that can be clearly defended before the court.

Mediation: an alternative worth considering

Where the conflict allows, mediation can be a way to reach agreements without going through contested proceedings. A neutral person helps the parties communicate and look for solutions, particularly on matters affecting the children.

It isn’t suitable in every situation, and it’s worth discussing with your lawyer. But when it’s possible, it often reduces the emotional toll on the whole family.

How we can help at Institut PSIRA

Our Forensic Psychology Unit carries out psychological assessments and expert reports in civil law for courts, lawyers and families: custody and contact, parenting capacity, adoption and fostering, psychological harm, guardianship, separation and divorce, and witness credibility. Reports are prepared so that they can be submitted and defended in court.

The first appointment costs €70, the expert report is priced on request depending on the case, and mediation costs €50 per person. If, alongside the proceedings, you or your children need emotional support, you can find it in our adults unit or our children and young people’s unit, separately from the expert assessment.

You can book through Doctoralia, message us on WhatsApp at +34 621 404 235 or use the contact form.

When to ask for help

It may help to speak to our forensic psychology unit if:

  • Your lawyer suggests submitting a psychological expert report.
  • You are going through custody or contact proceedings and the children’s situation needs to be assessed.
  • You need to evidence the psychological effects of an event.
  • An adoption, fostering or guardianship process requires a psychological assessment.
  • You would like to explore mediation to reach agreements.

This article is for general information and does not replace an assessment by a health professional.

Let’s talk about your case

Book a first appointment and we’ll consider with you whether an expert report or mediation suits your situation.

or write to us using the form

More articles

All articles